• Most Highly Rated
    410+ google reviews
  • Top Rated Reviews

Key AAT & Court Cases

  • High Success
    Rate
  • Excellent Service
    Guaranteed

    Request a Call back for a Consultation


    or

    Call us at (02) 9286 8700

    Key Court Cases of Parish Patience

    Parish Patience has been instrumental in initiating many groundbreaking cases that have created legal precedents in Immigration and Human rights history in Australia.

    Parish Patience Immigration Lawyers was solicitor for Plaintiff S157/2002, in the landmark Australian constitutional law cases, Plaintiff S157 of 2002 (2003) HCA 2 and Bodruddaza v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2007) HCA14. These cases protected the rule of law in Australia by confirming Acts of Parliament as unlawful, to the extent that they sought to restrict the powers of the High Court entrenched in the Constitution. These cases were influential decisions not only in relation to immigration law but to administrative law generally and are an authority for the proposition that Parliament cannot restrict the availability of constitutional writs.

    Parish Patience Immigration Lawyers was solicitor who identified that the automatic cancellation of many student visas was unlawful. We filed an appeal in the now-publicised Federal Magistrates Court case of Uddin v Minister for Immigration (2005) FMCA 841 (7 June 2005). As a result of that case, approximately 8000 automatic student visa cancellations were administratively overturned.

    In the Waensila v minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 32 (11 march 2016),  all three Federal Court Justices making up the Full Bench Agreed with Parish Patience Immigration Lawyers that on onshore partner visa application for applicant who does not hold a substantive visa satisfy schedule 3 requirement at the time of decision not time of application.

    In 2013, in a decision of the Full Court in SZGIZ had effectively opened the door for renewed applications made on complementary protection grounds even if a previous application made on “refugee” grounds had been refused. Because of this case over 10000 of applicants received second chance to apply for a further refugee application in Australia. Etc…

    Need Visa Assistance?

    Talk to one of our Visa Experts Now.

    XCHQ and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2018] AATA 4280 (19 November 2018)

    – mandatory cancellation of visa – substantial criminal record – discretion to revoke cancellation of visa – whether there is another reason why the mandatory cancellation should be revoked – Ministerial Direction No. 65 – protection of the Australian community – nature and seriousness of conduct – possession of prohibited drug – possession of unauthorised firearm – assault – driving offences – resist officer in execution of duty – offences in prison – risk to the Australian community should conduct be repeated – best interests of minor children – expectations of the Australian community – strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia – extent of impediments if removed from Australia – decision set aside

    Mahmoud v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2018] FCCA 54 (8 February 2018)

    In this case, Judge Driver accepted our] argument that a desire to remain in Australia is not necessarily inconsistent with the formation of a mutual commitment to a shared life with another person. Judge Driver further accepted Mr Jones’s argument that a visa applicant’s motivation for entering a relationship is a relevant consideration for the Tribunal in considering a partner visa application. His Honour noted that the reasoning of the Tribunal disclosed that it created a false dichotomy between the applicant’s undoubted desire to remain in Australia and the existence of a genuine and continuing relationship with the sponsor. His Honour further concluded that the creation of that false dichotomy distracted the Tribunal from the essential visa criterion in s.5F of the Migration Act.

    Accordingly, Judge Driver held that jurisdictional error has been established.

    Bautista v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1114 (27 July 2018)

    MIGRATION – application for partner visa – appeal against dismissal by Federal Circuit Court of application for judicial review of Tribunal decision – where Tribunal sent appellant a letter pursuant to s 359A of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act) – where Tribunal extended period during which to respond to s 359A letter in accordance with s 359B(4) and reg 4.18A(4) and calculated the last day for response as 21 August 2014 – where appellant responded on 22 August 2014 – revocation of offer to attend hearing at the Tribunal under s 360 of the Act for failure to respond to s 359A letter within statutory time limit – effect of s 363A of the Act – whether Tribunal miscalculated length of prescribed further period under s 359B(4) of the Act– whether Tribunal erred by not conducting a hearing in accordance with s 360 of the Act MIGRATION – requirements for s 359A letter – whether the Tribunal failed to give the appellant clear particulars of information it considered would be the reason or part of the reason for affirming the decision under review – degree of particularity required in s 359A letter STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – interpretation of s 359B(4) of the Act –– interaction of s 359B(2) and s 359B(4) of the Act, and regs 4.17 and 4.18A of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations) – whether primary Judge erred in interpretation of reg 4.18A(4) – validity of reg 4.18A(4) of the Regulations – whether reg 4.18A(4) led to manifest arbitrariness or a result inconsistent with the intention of s 359B(4) of the Act – effect of invalidity of regulation prescribing statutory time limit – whether power under the Act is dependent on existence of prescription by regulation – whether time requirement can be read into s 359B(4) in the absence of prescription by regulation

    Recent AAT Review Application won by
    Parish Patience:

    Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013]

    Mirdan v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2015]

    AEG15 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2015]

    SZVJE & Ors v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2016]

    SZUDH v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2016]

    Muhammad and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2016]

    Irani and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection
    (Migration) [2017]

    Singh v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017]

    SZVSK v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017]

    ACY18 v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor [2018]

    AFD17 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2018]

    Elhendy v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2018]

    XCHQ and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2018]

    ENV17 & Ors v Minister for Immigration & Anor (No.2) [2018]

    Mahmoud v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2018]

    Ferdous v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor [2019]

    HWLJ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020]

    Mejias Gallardo and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2020]

    BYT20 v Minister for Home Affairs [2020]

    Kaur v Bangari and Karyal Pty Ltd trading as India Gate
    Warrnambool & Anor [2020]

    Need Visa Assistance?

    Talk to one of our Visa Experts Now.

    1826690 (Refugee) [2023]

    2014524 (Refugee) [2022]

    1820127 (Refugee) [2022]

    1711561 (Refugee) [2022]

    1708746 (Refugee) [2022]

    1706681 (Refugee) [2022]

    1621951 (Refugee) [2022]

    1821622 (Refugee) [2020]

    1713796 (Refugee) [2021]

    1923311 (Migration) [2022]

    Safe Solutions Australia Pty Ltd (Migration) [2022]

    HUSSAIN (Migration) [2022]

    KHELA GROUP OF COMPANIES PTY LTD (Migration) [2021]

    Rahman (Migration) [2020]

    Mr Rafiqul Alam Khan (Migration) [2020]

    We Can Also Help You With

    Success Stories of 410 Highly Rated Reviews


    Our customers are always happy to share their thoughts with us.
    Here is what some of them had said!

    Haroon Parvez

    The team at parish Patience Immigration Lawyers were incredibly helpful throughout the application process. Their assistance made our lives so much less stressful and their expertise cleared up any confusion we had. They remained engaged with us the whole time and quickly responded to any questions with thoughtful, detailed answers. Special thanks to Usman Ali and Shan . We highly recommend the team at Parish patience immigration lawyer for anyone considering help regarding any kind of visa .

    W. A.

    Highly recommended lawyers! Extremely professional and reliable service, with outstanding outcomes. A special thanks to Mr Thong and Marlene, for helping us with our difficult case. Not only did they ensure that everything was ready to go, but their professionalism came in favor when we were granted our visa within just under 6 months!

    J P

    Thong and Marlene helped my partner gain permanent residency in Australia. We did the application ourselves but it turned out lots of information we needed to provide was missing. Thong and Marlene picked our case up and helped amend it. I really appreciate their help and guidance and look forward to contacting them again in the future. I am pleased by their efforts and professionalism.

    Alaa Omer

    Successfully handled my case. He had been prompt, caring and very professional in dealing with my case. I am glad to have received very strong support, guidance and service from them. I would highly recommend Parish patience immigration lawyers. I wish the best for their future prospects.

    Jabir Ibna Mohammad

    I’m really thankful for the guidance and assistance I’ve received regarding my Partner visa from Shan and his assistance Asha at Parish Patience. They handled my matter professionally and there were clear instructions from the beginning till end. I got my partner visa 820 granted in less than 7 months, thanks to their knowledge and expertise. I wish them all the best and highly recommend Parish Patience Immigration Lawyers for any sort of immigration matters.

    Get Legal Visa Advice From Parish Patience


    Overwhelmed by the mountain of requirements and time it will take to process a visa? You’ve got yourself a legal partner with Parish Patience. Over the years we have helped win legal cases for visa applications and appeals for clients from all over the world. Our visa services and solutions are personalised for each client’s unique circumstances. Whether you require advice or full assistance from consultation to application, we can help. Book an appointment now and speak to an Australian immigration agent soon.

    Our Accreditations

      Solve your Visa Problems


      Parish Patience Immigration Lawyers Sydney
      Parish Patience Immigration Lawyers Sydney
      381 Google reviews
      Sadia Ahmed
      Sadia Ahmed
      2024-03-13
      Usman looked after my file and we are granted 189 today . Very supportive team
      T Malhi
      T Malhi
      2024-03-07
      I would like to express my sincere gratitude to Parish Patience for the exceptional service they provided throughout my journey from Winning MRT(student visa ), 485 Visa and another student visa extensions to finally obtaining skilled migration. Usman demonstrated remarkable expertise and unwavering patience in addressing all my inquiries. I never felt the need to persistently follow up for updates on my application. His consistently kind, generous, and positive demeanor was truly commendable. I highly recommend Usman's services and extend my heartfelt appreciation to him.Thank you, Usman for bringing joy to those who have lost hope. You should be proud of the work you do
      Yaad Matharu
      Yaad Matharu
      2024-03-07
      I highly recommend their service. I would like to express my gratitude to Mr. Usman for his exceptional professionalism and expertise.
      Umer Saeed
      Umer Saeed
      2024-03-04
      Very professional, high standards of service and comprehensive knowledge of immigration, i strongly recommend them to anyone who requires immigration advice.
      Safat Aqib
      Safat Aqib
      2024-02-27
      I received excellent service from Parish patience. Usman and Billah were extremely proficient and courteous, and they assisted me throughout every stage. I strongly recommend them to anyone who requires immigration advice.
      Kanika Dua
      Kanika Dua
      2024-02-22
      Hi Just want to share my recent experience with parish patience. I was depressed and hopeless about my case and MR PRASAD at parish patience gave me hope and prepared my file very strong so I win in the AAT hearing. The case is in my favour now and hopefully i will get PR very soon. Highly recommend their service. They all are professionals and experts in their fields.
      Anand Inbasekaran
      Anand Inbasekaran
      2024-02-19
      I thank Upasna for making the visa process smooth and stress- free. Her attention to detail, prompt responsiveness, and in-depth knowledge of immigration procedures reflect a high standard of service. It was a pleasure to work with Parish Patience, and I would confidently recommend your services to others.
      Thihan Oo
      Thihan Oo
      2024-02-17
      Very happy and grateful for your services, fast, reliable, approachable and super efficient team, Shan and Asha, you guys are the best.
      Sarma B
      Sarma B
      2024-02-16
      I can't express enough gratitude for the outstanding service provided by my lawyer in helping me secure my partner visa. From the moment I walked into their office, I felt reassured by their warm demeanor and professionalism. Throughout the entire process, they were not only knowledgeable but also incredibly supportive, guiding me through each step with patience and clarity. What truly sets them apart is their accessibility. Whenever I had a question or concern, they were readily available, promptly responding to calls and emails, which alleviated any anxiety I had about the process. Their dedication to their clients is truly commendable. Thanks to their expertise and unwavering support, I am now able to build a future with my partner without the stress of immigration uncertainties. I wholeheartedly recommend their services to anyone in need of legal assistance, especially for partner visas. Thank you immensely for your outstanding representation!
      Rohan chowdhury
      Rohan chowdhury
      2024-02-06
      Usman Ali is by far one of the best lawyers I’ve met, very knowledgeable, very professional, calm, supportive, prompt in replying with his emails, basically everything that you look in a lawyer. He made the process unbelievable quick, effective and successful. Heartily thankful for him and the whole team.